After longtime sellers closed their shops over an AI-training clause, Etsy told The New York Times it will rewrite the policy.

Etsy is promising to rewrite a new terms-of-use clause after handmade sellers began closing long-running shops rather than let the company and its partners train artificial intelligence on their work. The terms are still scheduled to take effect on Dec. 16, and Etsy has not yet published the new wording.

According to The New York Times‘s Reggie Ugwu, language in the updated terms says Etsy and its “third party partners and vendors” reserve the right to use sellers’ content to “develop, train, test and improve artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies.” Ugwu reported that the previous version of the terms did not include a clause about using content for artificial intelligence, and that in a statement emailed to the Times on Friday, Etsy said it would revise the policy after hearing complaints from sellers.

The clause that started the walkouts

Engadget‘s Mariella Moon, citing the Times, wrote that sellers of handmade goods have been leaving the platform out of concern that their artwork and creations would be taken for AI training. The Times reported that last week, illustrator Aaron Millard said on Instagram that he was deleting the shop he has run for nearly a decade.

“Etsy decided that selling on their platform now means letting them train AI on our artwork AND resell that data to third parties, with no way to opt out,” Millard wrote, according to the Times. “My work took years to learn and create. I won’t let it be stolen.”

The Next Web, also citing Ugwu’s reporting, said Kristen and Geoff Zephyrus deleted the shop they have run for 13 years as Cognitive Surplus, selling home goods and stationery. “For Etsy to be helping to train algorithms with our human content is just unimaginably awful,” Kristen Zephyrus told the Times.

What Etsy says the language actually means

James Ossman, Etsy’s vice president of customer operations, addressed sellers in a post on the company’s website this week. According to Engadget, Ossman said the new wording was meant to clarify how Etsy already uses AI on the marketplace, not to change that practice.

“We do not use your content to train AI models designed to copy your original work or replace your creativity,” Ossman said, as quoted by Engadget. “Again, this is not changing. Our goal at Etsy has always been to connect you and your unique items with buyers.” He also said sellers’ content belongs to them, and that Etsy does “not claim [their] creations as [its] own or give others the right to do so.”

Ossman listed several uses for sellers’ content, Engadget reported: automatic translations of listing descriptions, featuring listings in marketing campaigns, and training models for shop tools such as listing optimization and performance summaries. He said Etsy blocks AI crawlers from scraping listings to train models, while acknowledging that some third-party partners are given access to sellers’ content for services such as fraud detection and helping buyers discover items off Etsy.

The Verge‘s Stevie Bonifield reported that Ossman told the Times Etsy plans to “share the revised terms directly with sellers soon.”

A familiar fight, and a mixed message on AI

The Next Web noted that this is not Etsy’s first seller revolt. In 2022, more than 20,000 sellers went on strike after the company raised its basic sales fee from 5% to 6.5%. In October, the Times reported, Etsy also tightened its rules on low-quality AI content after users complained.

That October update, described by Ossman in an Etsy announcement, requires listings to include at least one unedited photo of the actual item against a real background, bans bot-generated listings without human involvement, and prohibits AI-created functional guides such as patterns, recipes and instructions. The two moves landed in the same season: tighter rules on AI-made listings, and a contract clause expanding Etsy’s rights to train models on human-made work.

The Next Web also pointed to an opinion by Tyler Wilde, PC Gamer’s U.S. editor-in-chief, who argued that the clause reads like blanket permission to train AI on user content and that Etsy should leave sellers out of training by default.

Takeaway

For independent sellers and other creators, the fight is a familiar one. Platforms are writing AI-training rights into their terms, often with no clear way to opt out, and a walkout is one of the few levers small shops have. Etsy’s promise to revise the policy shows that pressure can still force a rewrite. It does not yet show what the new terms will say, or whether sellers will get a real chance to say no before Dec. 16.

Featured image: Silar, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.