Patreon’s first chief marketing officer, Mike McGarry, wants to sell creators on “relationships, not reach” as frustration with social media algorithms grows.
Patreon has a new marketing boss, and his pitch is aimed straight at creators who are tired of chasing the algorithm. According to The Drum‘s Jennifer Faull, Mike McGarry, Patreon’s newly appointed chief marketing officer, sees creators’ growing doubts about the big social platforms as a major opening for the company. His goal is to make Patreon a household name.
The bargain creators are questioning
Faull describes the problem plainly: creators built their audiences on Instagram, Facebook, YouTube and TikTok, but when those platforms change their algorithms, creators have to scramble to keep their reach and their income. The platforms give them eyeballs, but never full control.
McGarry believes the industry has reached a point where more creators are questioning that deal, The Drum reported. His view is that the next chapter of the creator economy will be built on relationships, not reach.
From payments to a full platform
According to MarkHub24, McGarry was promoted to Patreon’s first-ever CMO in September 2026 after joining the company in early 2025 as its first senior vice president of marketing. His job covers growing consumer discovery, bringing in new audiences and helping creators turn their communities into steady income.
That push comes as Patreon has grown well beyond a simple “support me” button. MarkHub24 noted the company has added native video, chat, discovery, short posts, a feed and free memberships. Citing past interviews with co-founder and CEO Jack Conte, the outlet said free memberships work like a follow: when a creator posts, Patreon sends emails and ranks those posts above other content so followers actually see them.
Conte has put some big numbers behind that strategy, MarkHub24 reported: 185 million free memberships, about double the year before, roughly 35 million chat messages and 110 million hours of video watched. Those are company figures from an interview, not independently checked data.
The catch
There’s an obvious tension here. Patreon built its name as the alternative to algorithm-driven social media, and now it runs its own feed and discovery tools. Back in August, The Verge‘s Jess Weatherbed reported that Patreon was overhauling its discovery algorithm to compare posts by topic, style and themes instead of recommending creators based on who fans already follow, a change meant to help smaller creators get found. The same roadmap included a Clips tool for cutting short videos, topic-based communities called Niches and anti-scraping protections against AI.
According to MarkHub24, Conte has said Patreon’s algorithms aren’t built to maximize watch time or session time, and are instead focused on reliable reach and long-term creator-fan relationships. The real test, the outlet argued, is whether Patreon can help creators grow without turning into another platform where everyone fights for attention.
The takeaway
For creators, including adult creators who know better than anyone how fast a platform can cut off their reach, Patreon’s message hits a nerve: own the relationship with your fans instead of renting it from an algorithm. Social apps aren’t going away as the place to get discovered, but the money increasingly comes from fans who choose to follow and pay you directly. Whether Patreon can deliver on “relationships, not reach” is something creators will judge by their own numbers.
Image: AI-generated illustration.
